Lately, I’ve been seeing a lot of ads that proclaim that writing a book and making money through Amazon is quicker and easier now than ever.
But here’s the thing. It’s written via AI.
And here’s another thing. Amazon require you to say whether the book was written, in part or full, with AI.
Can you tell if a book is written by AI? Here are some things to look out for:
- Consistency in Style: AI-generated text often maintains a consistent style throughout the entire book. While this can be a strength, it might also lack the subtle variations and unique voice that human authors naturally incorporate.
- Repetition: AI might inadvertently repeat certain phrases or ideas more frequently than a human author would. This is because AI relies on patterns in the data it was trained on, which can sometimes lead to redundancy.
- Lack of Deep Emotional Insight: While AI can generate text that mimics human emotions, it may not capture the depth and nuance of genuine human experiences. The emotional arcs might feel somewhat flat or predictable.
- Predictable Plot Structures: AI tends to follow common narrative structures and tropes. If the plot feels overly formulaic or lacks unexpected twists, it might be a sign of AI authorship.
- Technical Perfection: AI-generated text is often grammatically flawless and free of typos. While this is generally a positive trait, it can sometimes make the text feel less “human” and more mechanical.
- Lack of Cultural and Contextual Nuance: AI might struggle with cultural references, idiomatic expressions, and context-specific nuances that human authors naturally incorporate into their writing.
That said, AI is constantly improving, and distinguishing between human and AI authorship is becoming increasingly challenging. The best AI-generated texts can be quite sophisticated and engaging, blurring the lines between human and machine creativity.
I asked AI to tell me how to tell if a book was by AI. The above is what it said. Scary isn’t it that it can look like something a human wrote.
While I’m not happy about books being written by AI, I’m happy to use it as another tool in my writing tool box.
I use it for brainstorming ideas. I might ask AI to come up with ten ways for a character to do something romantic, or ten story ideas for a Scottish basketball team. I then use those ideas to form further concepts from there. Sometimes the ideas are fantastic, and I want to use them as they are, but I always write the story in my own words.
Other AI tools that writers use, and might not be aware of, is Grammarly and Pro-Writing Aid. Both of these grammar programs will make suggestions for any errors it finds in your writing. Sometimes it is correct (yes, I do need a comma there) and sometimes it isn’t (This speech is in present tense, but the rest of the sentence is in past tense). It is the writer who has to decide which one to use and accept or ignore.
As things progress further, it will become harder to determine if a story is AI generated or not, as computers become more self-aware (I’m sure there’s a movie there…) If you aren’t comfortable with AI generated stories, then stick to the writers you know who write their own words and support them and their work.